Now, we all realise that the show began to take a consistent dive in writing quality sometime after the first few seasons, but I struggle to pinpoint when exactly. And I think a lot of people do, I haven’t really heard anyone give a solid answer to this.
The first few seasons had some bad episodes, but every show does. Especially those made in America where for some reason they don’t consider it a proper season unless it’s at least 20 episodes long, so there’s going to be a sizable amount of filler and trash even in the best shows.
I know people constantly like to blame Magical Mystery Cure as “the point of no return”, but I’m not so sure about that one. The whole episode was shockingly bad and brought on Alicorn Twilight rather abruptly, but that’s all it seemed to be. A shockingly bad episode with an abrupt conclusion to Twilight’s main character arc.
So that’s why I created this thread, so we can share observations and discuss. And hopefully ascertain the moment when our favourite show about wonderful cartoon ponies began it’s backwards slide into mediocrity and lazy writing.