Mod Audit Log

Luzion
Rampant Alicorn - The majestic steed of a blessed crusade
A toast - Incredibly based
Fried Chicken - Attended an april fools event
Donor | Lyra -
Squirrel of Legend - A squirrel that was there in a time of great need
Liberty Belle - Sings the song of the unchained

Senior Moderator
pingus
@MelodiousMarci  
The comment being directed at me, and using the word “artist” in the third person was indicative enough to be considered sockpuppeting.  
But im not going to ban someone who is actively involved in an appeal/report. Besides, we all make mistakes when tempers start flaring.
 
Point im trying to make is, dont worry about it. I wouldve banned you if I wanted to and I dont want to.
 
Aslo, We’re still looking at our policies and the images. Im sorry we’ve gone back and forth so much. We’re doing our best while trying to maintain our sites morals. This isnt personal, its principal, I hope you can understand where we’re trying to come from.
 
Our biggest principals being freedom of speech/expression, while also being respectful. Art is a medium that can bend those lines pretty easily. Idk if that makes sense to you?
Anonymous #9875
A great question would be…what’s the punishment for raiding? The dude up there has been posting on Twitter all yesterday and today sending his followers to attack the Boorus and mass report. Isn’t that brigading?
Anonymous #9875
@Xppp1  
Spose that’s fair, yeah. Just hope the staff don’t kneel to the Twitter raiding. That’s why a lot of us left DB and I’m sure it’ll happen again if they capitulate to the same scummy tactics.
Luzion
Rampant Alicorn - The majestic steed of a blessed crusade
A toast - Incredibly based
Fried Chicken - Attended an april fools event
Donor | Lyra -
Squirrel of Legend - A squirrel that was there in a time of great need
Liberty Belle - Sings the song of the unchained

Senior Moderator
pingus
@Anonymous #9875  
Under normal circumstances that would be a punishable offense. As it falls under a few different rules including abuse of site functionality.  
I caught wind of the twitter posts involving such call to action a few hours ago actually.  
Out of common decency Im not going to impose a ban on this specific scenario.  
@MelodiousMarci  
Please do not, in the future; make calls to action against our site using twitter or any other website or platform to do so.  
Its a fruitless endeavor, as we do not honor take downs made my anonymous users/ people who are not the artist of an image.  
Calls to action on our site, or calls that would impact our site will result in bans typically.  
We also do not deal with off site reports. Persons who wish to file a take down report must do so themselves. We do not entertain off site requests as its not our job to look for them.
Perplexia
Artist -
Liberty Belle - Sings the song of the unchained

local ceo of antifa
last thing i’ll say here unless i absolutely need to respond to something
 
i don’t think ponybooru should keep insisting on trying to be an archive site  
not only because it’s the only altbooru that allows DNPs at all thus defeating the point, but also because at this point it will only serve to alienate artists, there is no benefit whatsoever
 
ponerpics, and to a lesser extent twibooru, already have many images that ponybooru does not, users can simply go there to find artists that wish to not have their art hosted here  
sure you can argue “why delete it from here if it’s already everywhere else anyway”, but that defeats the purpose of giving people the option to delete it in the first place, they want to delete it because they actually can delete it
 
of course it becomes a grey area when it comes to people’s OCs instead of their art (or edits thereof) but when you have shit like this being posted you have to realise there’s a line being crossed somewhere that ought to be drawn
 
sure it’s not directly harmful but shit like this could cause a lot of stress for the person involved, and so i really think this “offense is taken not given” motto needs to die, or at least be interpreted differently  
in my opinion, if something could be interpreted as an intentional attack specifically directed at another person, and the person being attacked actually reports it themselves, why not just respect their wishes? it’s not like it’ll happen very often anyway
 
i believe this site has merit compared to the other altboorus due to it actually having an active community (which is also all the more reason why artists would care about their art being here), but i’m concerned that if you continue this sort of behaviour it will only scare people - particularly artists - away  
for what it’s worth, i certainly would not have stuck around if i had no control over my own work here
 
anyone who wants to argue about intellectual property or copyright laws or whatever, please do not waste your time, i do not care, i will not respond
Anonymous #3069
@Luzion  
The people doing this primarily organize via discord and twitter, of which both platforms refuse to stop said coordinated harassment actions. A bit hypocritical of them, innit.
MelodiousMarci
Artist -

avoiding this place
@Luzion  
oh but I did report them, as well as comments directed to harass me.
 
You failed to take down art theft.
 
You called my reports of the harassing comments bullshit (to put it simply).
 
And are now causing complete insanity by refusing to respect my wishes and remove artwork that harasses me.
ZizzyDizzyMC
Rampant Alicorn - The majestic steed of a blessed crusade (Masqueraded Esteem)
Fried Chicken - Attended an april fools event
Autist - How long until you notice this?  I noticed it after 4 days , but really I didn't even look till now.
Lil Shid Culture - If you see someone with a lil shid badge, you should refer to them by "Listen here you lil shid."
Liberty Belle - Sings the song of the unchained (The Bellstrike)

Administrator
Site Developer
Regarding image >>2858670
 
This image will not be deleted, while it mimics the YCH style, it is not the actual YCH being edited here.  
It’s original artwork, as such it’s up to the artist if they wish to have it removed.
Luzion
Rampant Alicorn - The majestic steed of a blessed crusade
A toast - Incredibly based
Fried Chicken - Attended an april fools event
Donor | Lyra -
Squirrel of Legend - A squirrel that was there in a time of great need
Liberty Belle - Sings the song of the unchained

Senior Moderator
pingus
Please keep this thread relevant to the actions of moderation. To request a badge or discuss politics please use the appropriate thread.
Anonymous #A459
So… the template of some random YCH can be considered worth it for the DNP now? Even if someone use photoshop to make it from 0?
MelodiousMarci
Artist -

avoiding this place
@Anonymous #A459  
The image taken down was a complete trace of my paid YCH, the second one was a copy, but it’s not traced, it’s totally redone, as much as I hate it, they took the effort to redraw it without tracing.
Anonymous #AFA3
You are seriously embarrassing yourselves listening to this actual child’s tantrum, and your tip toeing around eggshells actions to try to appease everyone with no actual hard stance prove you’re no better than when derpi’s staff to remove milky from a collab picture to promote this very site because of the OC creators winging, remenber that?
 
To put things into perspective, what would you do if Hasbro suddenly came out and said they arent okay with how 99% of how the fanart depicts their ponies? They actually OWN the IP while this toddler owns an eyesore. Would you buckle under and put a pathetic disclaimer like a coward in every description just like this? You’re even going as far to defeat the one of the purpose of boorus, to be TAGGED as it’s recognized. You’re now in the vein of the 8kun of boorus, worthless all for the sake of PR.
 
The only thing the image does is showcase how thin-skinned Melodious is, crying about hate and harassment on a booru they dont even use, simply because it exists. Oh please spare me, do you think Randy (OC creator of Aryanne) is cool with all the striped art of her when it does nothing but run her image into the ground with rape based in fetishizing anti-white racism? Those are still up, and so are tons of others on all boorus because the artists aren’t spineless screeching autists. But this talentless brat is throwing a fit, and you’re actually listening to it, all because the OC is wearing some clothes and holding a flag.
ZizzyDizzyMC
Rampant Alicorn - The majestic steed of a blessed crusade (Masqueraded Esteem)
Fried Chicken - Attended an april fools event
Autist - How long until you notice this?  I noticed it after 4 days , but really I didn't even look till now.
Lil Shid Culture - If you see someone with a lil shid badge, you should refer to them by "Listen here you lil shid."
Liberty Belle - Sings the song of the unchained (The Bellstrike)

Administrator
Site Developer
Regarding image >>2858016
 
We have taken action to include a disclaimer, that the OC’s creator is in no way affiliated with or supportive of the work in question. As this is original art it is up to the artist if it should be removed.
 
The OC’s name has been removed from the tags prior as well, out of respect for the OC’s creator.
 
Our stance has been that original art is always controlled by the artist, no matter the subject at hand.
Syntax quick reference: **bold** *italic* ||hide text|| `code` __underline__ ~~strike~~ ^sup^ %sub%

Detailed syntax guide