I figured this might consider being more acceptable to people than just replacing Twilight in the group. Now everybody gets replaced!
 
 
Fleetfoot - Rainbow Dash. Originally, Spitfire was going to be here, but that would be two yellow ponies, so Fleetfoot took her place.
 
Glory - Rarity. I couldn’t find a unicorn pony that wasn’t a complete snob from FiM… So I just used a G1 pony.
 
Cermella - Applejack. I used one of Applejack’s family members from Apple Family Reunion who had a unique design. I was going to use Cheerilee, but I figured just using another Apple family member was a better choice.
 
Coco - Fluttershy
 
Sunset - Twilight
 
Surprise - Pinkie. I couldn’t find a pony that matched Pinkie Pie’s personality in FiM.
 
Spike - …Spike, except he’s red this time. Totally original, right?
 

 
Background by MLP-Vector-Collabs  
Glory’s redesign by Sunley