Set during during the short “Winter Break-In. The Turtles and Rainbooms arrive at CHS, and after Twilight debunks all the girls plans to get the key Sunset left behind, they discover that the Color Strikes stopped by and took the key, claiming that Sunset had sent them.
 
They leave the school to find the Color Strikes outside waiting for them and gives them the toys for the kids. When asked why they did this, they explain that by doing this, they were hoping the Rainbooms would let them help out with giving toys away to kids, as they wanted to people that they changed, since they’ve had a bad rap after the pet show.
 
“You could have just asked,” Twilight pointed out.
 
“We would’ve been more than happy to let you all help,” Fluttershy added.
 
“Well, we weren’t sure, especially since Blue Boy over there has trust issues,” Belle pointed at Leo, who rubbed the back of his neck sheepishly.
 
“True, but I’ve learned to start giving people a second chances,” he said.
 
“But, if you guy really wanna show you’ve changed, I have an idea,” Mikey chimed in, before pointing at Twilight. “And no debunking it, Twi.”
 
Later, at the mall, Raph sat on a big chair, dressed as Santa Claus again. “Ho ho ho,” he said, dryly. “Who here’s been a good?” And all the kids exclaimed they were. “Good. Now Santa’s got some some special helpers here today. The Rainbooms!” The girls walked out and waved. “And the Color Strikes!”
 
The crowd fell silent. The girls could see the acapella singers were right about no one trusting them.
 
“Santa knows the Color Strikes have been naughty, but their going to sing a little song to Santa to proof their nice,” Raph told them, and muttered to himself. “Mikey’s plan better work, for making me dresscup in this.
 
 
Then Color Strikes appeared and began to sing…
 
 
[Belle]
 
This happens every year
 
It’s not the way I planned
 
I start out being good
 
And now I don’t know where I stand
 
I feel conflicted
 
My wicked ways are done
 
But come on, Santa
 
Tell me now we can’t have any fun?
 
A little mischief, a little spell
 
I know your watching
 
But there’s secrets I won’t tell
 
 
[Phasioner]
 
I think it’s pretty clear
 
My mirror never lies
 
I’ve goon from bad to good
 
Now, Santa, can’t you sympathize
 
 
[Lip Syncer]
 
I made a tiny slip
 
Can’t say I didn’t try
 
The queen of mean is gone
 
And now I got a better side
 
I turned my life around
 
Santa, can’t you see?
 
Cause there’s an angel on my shoulder
 
Where the devil used to be
 
 
[All three]
 
I made just one mistake or two
 
I don’t know what to dooooooooooo!
 
 
[Color Strikes]
 
Maybe I’m naughty, maybe I’m nice
 
You can call me sweet
 
Better think twice
 
I’ve done a lot of bad
 
But I’m trying to be good
 
Santa will forgive me
 
Like I knew that he would
 
I’ve been bad for so long
 
Now I’m rolling the dice
 
Santa, won’t you tell me
 
If I’m naughty or nice?
 
Naughty or nice
 
Naughty or nice
 
 
[Lip Syncer]
 
Santa, won’t you tell me
 
If I’m naughty or nice?
 
 
[Lucky Shot]
 
I love this time of year
 
Presents under the tree
 
I’m kind of worried
 
But I’m hoping that there’s one for me
 
 
[Lightning Crash]
 
Forget the things I did
 
The new me’s here to stay
 
But bend the rules
 
Now that’s CS holiday
 
 
[Lucky Shot]
 
How bout a little give
 
[Lightning Crash]
 
And then a lot of take
 
[Lucky Shot]
 
Hey wait, that isn’t fair!
 
[Lightning Crash]
 
Come on, give me a break
 
 
[Lucky Shot]
 
I made just one mistake or two
 
(With Lightning Crash)
 
I don’t know what to dooooooooooo
 
1 2 3 4
 
 
[Color Strikes]
 
Maybe I’m naughty, maybe I’m nice
 
You can call me sweet
 
Better think twice
 
I’ve done a lot of bad
 
But I’m trying to be good
 
Santa will forgive me
 
Like I knew that he would
 
I’ve been bad for so long
 
Now I’m rolling the dice
 
Santa, won’t you tell me
 
If I’m naughty or nice?
 
 
[Afromia]
 
From under the sea
 
To under the tree
 
The bad girl’s gone
 
At least for now
 
You got something for me?
 
Get your list, check it twice
 
Am I naughty
 
Am I nice
 
Tell me now
 
Cause I just can’t wait
 
Leave your sleigh, send it fay
 
I’ve mended my ways
 
Seen the light
 
CS villain to a sheer delight
 
What’s my name?
 
Say it here
 
Say I’m bad
 
Try again next year
 
 
[Peach Cream]
 
I hope it’s not too late for me to change my ways
 
[Hot Buns]
 
But there’s a side inside of me that comes out to play
 
[Botanica]
 
Just give me one more chance now before you go
 
[Color Kicker]
 
I wanna knooooooooooooooooowww
 
 
[Color Strikes]
 
Maybe I’m naughty, maybe I’m nice
 
You can call me sweet
 
Better think twice
 
I’ve done a lot of bad
 
But I’m trying to be good
 
Santa will forgive me
 
Like I knew that he would
 
I’ve been bad for so long
 
Now I’m rolling the dice
 
Santa, won’t you tell me
 
If I’m naughty or nice?
 
(Botanica: Oh, Santa)
 
Santa, won’t you tell me if I’m naughty or nice
 
(Lightning Crash: Santa won’t you tell me)
 
<Santa, please tell me that I’m nice, nice</i>
 
(Hot Buns: Am I naughty or nice)
 
Santa, won’t you tell me if I’m naughty or nice
 
(Lip Syncer: Ooh ooh ooh ooh)
 
Santa, please tell me that I’m nice, nice
 
 
[Lucky Shot]
 
Cause I’ve been bad for so long
 
[Lightning Crash]
 
Now I’m rolling the dice
 
[Afromia]
 
I know you made a list
 
And your checking twice
 
[Peach Cream]
 
Just a little bit of suger
 
[Color Kicker]
 
And a lot of spice
 
[Belle Harmony]
 
Santa, won’t you tell me if I’m naughty or nice
 
 
[Color Strikes]
 
Naughty or nice
 
Naughty or nice
 
 
[Lip Syncer]
 
Santa, won’t you tell me if I’m
 
Naughty or nice
 
 
“Hmm? Well, after giving it some thought,” Raph began. “I’ve decided… that you are… nice!”
 
All the kids cheered while the acapella singers smiled.
 
Soon they were helping the Rainbooms, Allies, and the disguised Turtles hand out presents to the kids.
 
“Well, that’s the last gift,” Color Kicker said.
 
“And we couldn’t have done it without you guys,” Sunset told the Color Strikes. “Now, who’s ready to go cash in some gift cards?” Everyone cheered, as she turned to Twilight. “Twilight, where’s that bag I gave you?”
 
“I left it at school!” Twilight gasped. But then she smiled and put on some shades. “But I’ve got an idea…”
 
 
Song “Naughty or Nice” from PattyCake Productions. Edited a bit by me.
 
Color Strikes by BozzerKazooers.
 
Equestria Ninja Girls by DarkMagicianmon.