Posts

@Anonymous #BF9B
Good things I can say about TYT is that the pony backsides look better and the times when Misty becomes a target for cartoonish violence are fairly entertaining.

@IvanSatoru
Hard disagree from me. I'll take the bean mouths and short stories that don't overstay their welcome over the lifeless and incompetent CGI I'm expected to look at for half an hour at a time or more.

TYT looks like a lost cause for any worthwhile entertainment. MYM isn't much better, but at least it looks less aesthetically revolting in some ways (ponies look more like ponies and less like Steven Stupiverse abominations)

@IvanSatoru
It's a rip of Misery Business by Paramore. At least I can listen to it without the juvenile angst and depression. Plus, it's better than stale acoustic pop.

!BANGER ALERT!
Whatever they ripped to write this song, it was the right stuff to rip off from.
Where'd It Go? is far superior to Portrait Day. Fight me.

"Everyone" seems to gush over Portrait of a Princess. It's really not that good. The song only sounds above generic because it sounds more acoustic than electronic. Otherwise it's still a generic-sounding 4 chord song.

@Adan Druego

was

Big F in the chat.

@Officer Hotpants
Somehow better than the end of FiM, where they'd incessantly force Twilight to be the protagonist and then wonder why the new characters are so severely underdeveloped.

If there's anything that could redeem G5, it's if they give Misty a proper redemption arc and make her the real protagonist who actually learns about friendship. Give us Starlight's redemption arc but done properly instead of "she's good now."

@IvanSatoru
Aw, Sunny's not useless. She's… advanced.

@πʊßƛįϰ
On second thought — Hitch should have Sunny. That way, he can have real foals so we could avoid the hideous dragon child thing and the retarded dragon dad idea entirely and also Sunny would stop being so useless. Edit: and also Hitch can go back to doing sheriff things normally and being a real father figure with real blood in the game.

Just replace the dragon with a foal.

@πʊßƛįϰ

Cozy Glow (ˈkəʊzi gləʊ), also known as the Pegabomber (ˈpɛgəsəsbɑmər), was an Equestrian villain…

@πʊßƛįϰ
I didn't even think about Sunny. Which is especially bad given that she's supposed to be the primary character. Jesus Christ. The new alicorn lead is so forgettable that I have to be reminded she exists.

@Adan Druego
When you put it that way, I'll add a new missed FiM opportunity to the list: the opportunity to treat Cozy as the Theodore Kaczynski of Equestria.


@IvanSatoru
Too many dimensions.

@Fleur de Lis
I agree with your conclusion. FiM had some real stinkers. G5 has mostly been just kind of there—its biggest WTF moments are all in how it keeps milking Twilight Sparkle's dead body. G5 when it's just G5 would be pretty OK if they had the budget to make the animation good and add more songs.

@IvanSatoru
I agree with the 7. Neither of them seem like sex-crazed maniacs, but I can imagine Zipp falling for Hitch because he's a far more suitable suitor to be her prince consort than the stallions Haven tries to set her up with back home. It also gets Hitch out of Sunny's options to force Sunny to accept Izzy's advances.

@IvanSatoru
Enh. I'll give it a 7. I like them.

@Cyborg_pony
There are a lot of stupid people saying a lot of stupid stuff


Rate ship

@IvanSatoru
Weren't there people also memeing that G4 was dead and celebrating G5, while this show rides it's coattails like the wife of a celebrity?

Why does Twiggy look like she's on botox?

Oh yeah — bring Sunny's braid back. What was the point of getting rid of it? It looked good. Is it because muh symbolisms? And ditch the ugly Romanian flag stripe. Who even thought that was a good idea?

@Fleur de Lis
Yeah, she's got a minor case of OC Colors. Still not a bad design, though.

I really like the movement of the joint above the hoof here.

ALL of the G4 alicorns had far better colour schemes though.

So, Make Your Mark Chapter 2. Not bad, and there is a lot that is enjoyable enough, but G5 still lacks the believability of early G4, which made it something more than a show I would watch once and never care about again.

In conclusion: Meh.

@ANoobis
I immediately thought of Cozy Glow. She tried to basically vacuum up all of Equestria's magic. While Tirek wanted the magic to empower himself, Cozy was just going to essentially displace it into some other dimension, thus leaving ponies magicless but still capable. If I remember correctly, pegasi even lost their flight due to Cozy's actions, so G5 starting scenario achieved.

You think there was a part of Starlight and Discord that was miffed by Twilight taking the magic away? They were both treated like villains when they did it.

Posey had no reason to apologize.

I liked the concept of earth pony magic in g4. It was very subtle yet unmistakeable to anyone who paid attention. It was special and very distinct from the other types of magic. In g5, earth ponies grow mature plants instantly. I guess that's cool, but it's not subtle at all.

The magic comes back, and with just one day— even just a few hours —of practice, or heck, even no practice at all, they become skilled as if they've been doing it for years. And if they're being mean to each other, the magic turns off.

Movie Hitch was great. Why couldn't they just keep him like that? ANSWER ME, CHRIS.