After the Enterprise visited Sha-Ka-Ree in 2287, along with Sybok’s sacrifice, the god underwent a slow transformation to repair itself, first extracting EG Pinkie Pie’s (who died very long ago in 2097 from old age) soul from the dead. Soon, in 2322, the transformation completes. Now instead of the godly bearded face seen by Kirk, it’s facial avatar looks, acts, and sounds like Pinkie. It even now has Pinkie’s memories.
Sha-Ka-Ree wouldn’t be visited again until 2403, when the USS Sunset Shimmer dropped out of geode drive near the planet (even safely zipping through the barrier) after the magical geode core malfunctioned. Captain Becky Ray Shoichet would instantly recognize the planet as the one Kirk visited after the Nimbus III incident. Having no choice, she and her crew beamed down to the planet. However, unlike last time, the atmosphere and ecosystem of Sha-Ka-Ree had changed into a more “Candy Land”-like setting. Soon after, Shoichet would be surprised to see the “fake god” is now Pinkie. The now goddess Pinkie would also recognize Shoichet from when she time traveled to 2019 to protect Sunset from the Arida. Soon, the god Pinkie would help Shoichet repair the Sunset Shimmer. Looking at the ship, the god Pinkie would also recognize the name of her old friend, who she remembers going to PostCrush concerts with.